Do I give my US property manager a W-8BEN or a W-8ECI for rent?
Give a W-8ECI if you have made, or are making, the section 871(d) election to treat the rent as effectively connected income, and a W-8BEN only if you are leaving the rent on the default basis, taxed at 30% because it is not effectively connected. The IRS instructions say not to use a W-8BEN for effectively connected income, and a W-8ECI is not valid without a US taxpayer identification number such as an ITIN.
Who this applies to: Canadian residents (nonresident aliens for US tax) whose US rent is paid through a property manager or other payer.
- Rent left as FDAP
- W-8BEN; 30% of gross withheld
- 871(d) election made
- W-8ECI; no withholding on that rent
- W-8ECI needs
- A US TIN, such as an ITIN
- W-8ECI valid until
- End of the third calendar year after signing
How it works
The form follows the tax treatment, not the other way round. Rent from US real property owned by a nonresident alien is taxed at 30% if it is not effectively connected with a US trade or business; with the 871(d) election, net income from the property is taxed at graduated rates instead. A W-8BEN keeps the payer on the 30% basis, and a W-8ECI tells the payer the rent is effectively connected, on which no withholding is required.
A W-8ECI is a commitment, not just a withholding form. In giving it, you state under penalties of perjury that the rent is effectively connected and includible in your income, and a nonresident alien with an 871(d) election must file Form 1040-NR for the first year and every year after until the election is revoked.
The form goes to the payer, not to the IRS. A W-8ECI generally stays valid until the last day of the third calendar year after the year you sign it, unless a change in circumstances makes something on it incorrect, so it has to be renewed on a schedule.
A W-8BEN already on file does not convert itself when you make the election. The IRS says that once income covered by a W-8BEN becomes effectively connected, the W-8BEN is no longer valid for that income and you must file a W-8ECI, and the W-8ECI needs a TIN to be valid, so the ITIN has to exist before the 30% can stop.
Source: IRS Instructions for Form W-8BEN; Instructions for Form W-8ECI; IRS, Nonresident aliens: real property located in the U.S.; IRS Publication 519.
Go deeper: Section 871(d) decision tool
Terms used here
Related questions
Frequently asked questions
Do I send the W-8ECI to the IRS?
Can I give a W-8ECI before my ITIN arrives?
This is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules change and your situation is specific — verify with the CRA or IRS, or with a cross-border advisor, before acting. ← All answers
BorderBird helps cross-border landlords track rent and prepare CRA NR4 and IRS Schedule E filings — see how it works.