BorderBird
United States / IRS

Do I give my US property manager a W-8BEN or a W-8ECI for rent?

Give a W-8ECI if you have made, or are making, the section 871(d) election to treat the rent as effectively connected income, and a W-8BEN only if you are leaving the rent on the default basis, taxed at 30% because it is not effectively connected. The IRS instructions say not to use a W-8BEN for effectively connected income, and a W-8ECI is not valid without a US taxpayer identification number such as an ITIN.

Who this applies to: Canadian residents (nonresident aliens for US tax) whose US rent is paid through a property manager or other payer.

Key facts
Rent left as FDAP
W-8BEN; 30% of gross withheld
871(d) election made
W-8ECI; no withholding on that rent
W-8ECI needs
A US TIN, such as an ITIN
W-8ECI valid until
End of the third calendar year after signing

How it works

The form follows the tax treatment, not the other way round. Rent from US real property owned by a nonresident alien is taxed at 30% if it is not effectively connected with a US trade or business; with the 871(d) election, net income from the property is taxed at graduated rates instead. A W-8BEN keeps the payer on the 30% basis, and a W-8ECI tells the payer the rent is effectively connected, on which no withholding is required.

A W-8ECI is a commitment, not just a withholding form. In giving it, you state under penalties of perjury that the rent is effectively connected and includible in your income, and a nonresident alien with an 871(d) election must file Form 1040-NR for the first year and every year after until the election is revoked.

The form goes to the payer, not to the IRS. A W-8ECI generally stays valid until the last day of the third calendar year after the year you sign it, unless a change in circumstances makes something on it incorrect, so it has to be renewed on a schedule.

Where people get caught

A W-8BEN already on file does not convert itself when you make the election. The IRS says that once income covered by a W-8BEN becomes effectively connected, the W-8BEN is no longer valid for that income and you must file a W-8ECI, and the W-8ECI needs a TIN to be valid, so the ITIN has to exist before the 30% can stop.

Source: IRS Instructions for Form W-8BEN; Instructions for Form W-8ECI; IRS, Nonresident aliens: real property located in the U.S.; IRS Publication 519.

Terms used here

Related questions

Frequently asked questions

Do I send the W-8ECI to the IRS?
No. The IRS says not to send Form W-8ECI to the IRS but to give it to the person requesting it, which is generally the person who pays you the rent, such as your property manager.
Can I give a W-8ECI before my ITIN arrives?
Not a valid one. The instructions say a TIN is required for the form to be valid, and a payer without valid documentation from you can withhold at the 30% foreign-person rate, so expect withholding to continue until the ITIN is issued and an updated W-8ECI is on file.

This is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules change and your situation is specific — verify with the CRA or IRS, or with a cross-border advisor, before acting. ← All answers

BorderBird helps cross-border landlords track rent and prepare CRA NR4 and IRS Schedule E filings — see how it works.