Do I need Form 8840 if I spend winters in the US and own a rental?
You need Form 8840 if your days in the US meet the substantial presence test and you want to stay a nonresident through the closer connection exception, which requires fewer than 183 days in the US that year and a closer connection to Canada. Owning a rental does not change the day count, but if you file a US return for it, you attach Form 8840 to that return.
Who this applies to: Canadian residents who spend winters in the US and own rental property in either country.
- Needed when
- You meet the substantial presence test
- Exception day limit
- Fewer than 183 days in the US that year
- Filing a US return
- Attach Form 8840 to it
- No US return
- Send it to the IRS by the return due date
How it works
The substantial presence test needs 31 days this year and 183 days over three years, counting all of this year's days, one third of last year's and one sixth of the year before. In the IRS's own example, 120 days in each of three years totals 180 and does not meet the test. Stay 150 days each winter and the count is 150 + 50 + 25 = 225, which does. Part days count. You are treated as present in the US on any day you are physically there at any time during the day, so the drive down and the drive home both go in the total.
The exception has conditions beyond the 183 days: a closer connection to one foreign country where you had a tax home, a tax home there for the entire year, and no steps taken toward a green card.
The rental decides where the form goes. If you file a US federal return for a US rental, such as Form 1040-NR, Form 8840 is attached to it. If you have no US return to file, you send Form 8840 to the IRS service center on its own by the due date for filing the return.
Late can be the same as never. The IRS says that if you do not file Form 8840 on time you cannot claim the closer connection exception, unless you can show by clear and convincing evidence that you took reasonable steps to comply. A snowbird who meets the test and skips the form can be treated as a US resident alien, and resident aliens are generally taxed in the US on income from all sources, including the Canadian rental.
Source: IRS, Substantial presence test; IRS, Closer connection exception to the substantial presence test; CRA, Canadian residents going down south.
Terms used here
Related questions
Frequently asked questions
Do I need Form 8840 if I don't meet the substantial presence test?
Does Canada still tax me while I winter in the US?
This is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules change and your situation is specific — verify with the CRA or IRS, or with a cross-border advisor, before acting. ← All answers
BorderBird helps cross-border landlords track rent and prepare CRA NR4 and IRS Schedule E filings — see how it works.